Nurturing kids' natural ability to question

One day, a student and his dad arrived in class with a little package. It turned out to be an empty nest they had found in their garden. My students eagerly gathered around it to see it up close.

"What if the mummy bird is still looking for it?" one worried boy asked. They all looked at me but I shrugged and kept inspecting the nest.

I was thinking about the lesson ahead and decided to shelf it. Long division could wait. The Grade 3s were learning about natural structures and this was a perfect chance to let inquiry flow.

I Step Back,

They Move Forward.

We then used SEE THINK WONDER, an often used, yet simple and powerful tool to organize our thoughts.

By now, my Grade 3s are readily able to identify HOT and LOT questions (higher/lower order thinking).
Their sheets filled up with their wondering. I noticed there were quite a few

Why...
What if...
I wonder why...

Here is our attempt at building a birds nest, Beijing National Stadium, China.

As each group read out their questions, we slightly tweaked the Why Do You Say That routine to Why Do You Ask That? It worked really well for this particular question:

A: "Why did you ask that?"

B: "I asked that because the bird could have built a bigger more spacious nest. Also, small birds could build big nests and big birds could build small nests!"

A: "Why does it need a lot of space? "

B: "Would you like to live in cramped conditions?"

C: "But the nest's purpose is to keep the eggs warm! Too much space would allow air to flow in between and this would cool them.
A: "They might roll against each other and the eggs could then crack."

Back and forth they went. I love the fact that the student who asked the last question was undaunted because he genuinely felt that the size of the bird was not related to the size of the nest.

We then proceeded to sort out questions into concepts just to see where we were headed with our inquiry. The students sorted the questions without any help from me. They were spot on! Their discussions helped me understand what they understood about conceptual questions.

Since there was hardly any "Change" questions, I challenged them to come up with some.

"Is the nest strong enough to last another year for the next batch of eggs?"

Which led to, " Does a bird use the same nest or build a new one?"

"Why do nests have different shapes?"

"What would a bird do if her nest was destroyed but she still needed it for her eggs? "

With these questions burning in their minds, the students are now revved up and determined to find out more.

Cultivate ignorance instead of fearing it. Firestein S. (2012)

Comments

Generalization-Designing Your Lessons for Conceptual Understanding (Part 3)

This post is the third of our blog post series on how to design lessons for conceptual understanding. Part 1 here Part 2 here Strategy 3 : Generalizations You may have come across Lynn Erickson's diagram on the structure of knowledge. In my IB workshop's I always like to present the avocado model alongside this diagram when I am talking about facts. The intention of inquiry-based teaching and conceptually-driven understanding (or Concept-based inquiry- whatever terminology suits your fancy) is to enable students to make generalizations. In other words, can they transfer their learning to a new context because they have understood what they learnt. In order to make generalizations, we need to first plan lessons that help students acquire facts/topics that are interesting and worth knowing. Bringing in local and global issues that are relevant to the topic help students as they begin to compare the topics and see emerging patterns. Remember, facts and concepts have a syn...

Classification -Designing Your Lessons for Conceptual Understanding (Part 1)

In this series, we will discuss how we can design lessons for conceptual understanding. Having recently completed an upskilling course with IB, I felt we may all benefit from looking at some of these strategies and how they might look like in our PYP classrooms. Strategy 1: Classification Source: Ibo.org In this post, I will be focusing on the research-backed strategy, "classification". Chadwick (2009) highlights that classification helps develop conceptual understanding by allowing students to organize information, recognize patterns, and understand relationships among concepts. Here are some examples across several disciplines on how I have used tools to classify. Math Class 1) In my math class (Grade 3) instead of having students simply rote learn the names of the shapes and their properties, have them sort the shapes based on the number of sides, angles and symmetry. Even better, use the Concept Attainment Strategy (I keep returning to this strategy be...

Concepts-In-Use: Designing your lessons for Conceptual Understanding (Part 6)

Concepts-In Use www.ibo.org In this post, one more strategy takes center stage when it comes to designing lessons that aid conceptual understanding in our students: Concept-In-Use. This strategy should be used once several concepts have been covered in class. A great way to know whether your students are internalizing the concepts is to ask them to explain the connections between two concepts. For example: In Math Ask them to convert a fraction to a percentage. Or a percentage to a decimal. Can they clearly explain the connection? Can they use drawings to support their explanation? Can they articulate the difference between a prism and a pyramid. How are they same? How are they different? How can you represent data visually? Bar graphs, pictographs, line charts are all concepts. As a designer of conceptual lessons, a teacher needs to be keenly aware of the connections between concepts. For instance, is the Grade 3 teacher awar...

Learning Never Stops

Search This Blog